Nov. 20, 2026

What Lawyers Get Wrong About Risk, with Ben Gideon and Jeff Wright

What Lawyers Get Wrong About Risk, with Ben Gideon and Jeff Wright
What Lawyers Get Wrong About Risk, with Ben Gideon and Jeff Wright
Elawvate: Build & Grow Your Law Firm
What Lawyers Get Wrong About Risk, with Ben Gideon and Jeff Wright

Treating risk as a bad thing costs lawyers real opportunities. Ben Gideon and Jeff Wright of Gideon Asen unpack why attorneys are wired to play it safe and how to tell a calculated risk from a reckless one. Ben borrows from poker, where a pro judges a hand by its expected value rather than its result, and explains how fear of loss skews our choices. It's why he still views turning down an $11 million offer as the right call, even after losing at trial. Jeff covers the other side of the ledger, sharing simple checks every firm should run so one bad outcome can't sink it. Tune in to learn when the safe choice could actually be the riskier one.

Learn More and Connect

☑️ Ben Gideon | LinkedIn | Facebook | Instagram

☑️ Jeff Wright | LinkedIn

☑️ Gideon Asen on LinkedIn | Facebook | YouTube | Instagram | X

☑️ Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube

Produced and Powered by LawPods, a podcast marketing agency for law firms

Sponsored by Supio and 1% for the Planet.

Speaker:

Great lawyers don't always know how to build great law firms.

Speaker:

Let's change that.

Speaker:

Join Ben Gideon as he shares hard won lessons from building his own financially

Speaker:

successful law firm and practical insights from top law firm entrepreneurs,

Speaker:

business consultants, and more.

Speaker:

This is a podcast for lawyers by lawyers.

Speaker:

Welcome to Elawvate, Build and Grow Your Law Firm.

Speaker:

Produced and powered by LawPods.

Speaker:

Welcome to Elawvate, Build and Grow Your Law Firm. I am Jeff Wright,

Speaker:

chief operating officer at Gideon Asen. As always, joined by our host,

Speaker:

Ben Gideon. Good morning, Ben.

Speaker:

Good morning, Jeff. What's new with you today?

Speaker:

Nothing. Just another Wednesday. We're coming off, I think,

Speaker:

a very unique team-building experience last week that our

Speaker:

firm had. I don't know if you want to tell people what we did.

Speaker:

Oh, right. Yes. I think our listeners would be very interested in this.

Speaker:

We should probably dedicate an episode or two to it.

Speaker:

I think so.

Speaker:

We had our first annual Fletch Night.

Speaker:

Fletch Night is a holiday we've created that consists of renting a

Speaker:

movie theater and watching the movie Fletch,

Speaker:

which for those who don't know is a great comedy from the '80s starring Chevy

Speaker:

Chase. There were sequels to it. None of them are any good.

Speaker:

The only good one is the very first one.

Speaker:

I know almost every line to Fletch by heart because when I was a kid,

Speaker:

we only owned one VHS movie in my house, Fletch.

Speaker:

So every time I'd come home,

Speaker:

I would just put it in and watch it at whatever place it left off.

Speaker:

So I've probably watched it thousands of times.

Speaker:

And I often reference lines from the movie in the office and nobody knows what

Speaker:

I'm talking about because our staff were all born in the '90s,

Speaker:

so they missed that whole decade.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So Fletch Night is not only Fletch, but in future years,

Speaker:

our Fletch Day movie will be a different,

Speaker:

important movie canon that will allow people to share a common

Speaker:

understanding and vocabulary so we can all communicate effectively.

Speaker:

So other movies that could potentially be on the list include things like Slap

Speaker:

Shot, maybe Airplane.

Speaker:

Dumb and Dumber.

Speaker:

Maybe Dumb and Dumber. Well, Dumb and Dumber,

Speaker:

I think we're moving into the '90s now anyway,

Speaker:

but you could go back with an Animal House or a Caddyshack,

Speaker:

but I don't want to overdo the Chevy Chase situation.

Speaker:

True.

Speaker:

Then you could get more serious. You could go for A Few Good Men.

Speaker:

You could go for Back to the Future. Anyway,

Speaker:

I don't know what the methodology for coming up with the next Fletch Day movie

Speaker:

will be.

Speaker:

It could be a short list of options and people could vote on them or we maybe

Speaker:

would just throw it out to everybody. But if we did that,

Speaker:

I'm worried about what might come back.

Speaker:

We'll end up watching The Princess Bride or something or Love Actually.

Speaker:

It's your biggest fear. Yeah,

Speaker:

I would say it was a rousing success and it was really out of necessity because

Speaker:

people needed to understand what the hell you were talking about with all these

Speaker:

comments you were making that nobody got.

Speaker:

So it gives the firm and the team a better understanding of your sense of humor.

Speaker:

So it was good.

Speaker:

Yeah. I mean, if you come in and say, "Could I borrow your towel?

Speaker:

My car just hit a water buffalo." They don't know what you're talking about.

Speaker:

Which is odd. I mean, everyone should know what that means.

Speaker:

You using the whole fist, Doc?

Speaker:

Jesus. All right.

Speaker:

What are you doing? A little stunt flying up there or something?

Speaker:

Things like that. Not going to sing for us, are you, Sammy?

Speaker:

From the Fred the Dorfman scene.

Speaker:

Oh, put it on the Underhills' tab.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

All right, let's transition back to something maybe not as important as that.

Speaker:

So the show as always is brought to you from 1% of the

Speaker:

Planet. As our listeners know,

Speaker:

it's something that our firm has been a part of for years.

Speaker:

We contribute 1% of the firm's revenue to causes

Speaker:

that are vetted by 1% for the Planet and they go to environmental causes

Speaker:

all around the world. And it's something that we believe in as a firm.

Speaker:

And as we grow,

Speaker:

our donations grow and we're more than happy to continue that.

Speaker:

If anyone does join 1% for the Planet,

Speaker:

please let Ben and I know and we would love to give you a shout out on the show.

Speaker:

Yeah. As you were saying, that 1% number keeps getting a lot bigger now.

Speaker:

It does.

Speaker:

It's a good feeling though to see that number grow year over year.

Speaker:

Definitely.

Speaker:

We're also brought to you by Supio,

Speaker:

the AI platform designed specifically for plaintiff trial lawyers.

Speaker:

I was just seeing some comments on a listserv that I participate in where

Speaker:

people were singing the praises of Supio and pointing out all the different

Speaker:

ways in which it's enhanced their businesses and their practices. Great company,

Speaker:

really well run, very thoughtful approach to AI, of course,

Speaker:

proprietary so you don't have to worry about confidentiality and so forth.

Speaker:

So check them out at supio.com.

Speaker:

So today's show,

Speaker:

and I don't want people to stop listening when I tell you what it's about

Speaker:

because we're going to make it interesting,

Speaker:

but today's show's going to be about risk and how lawyers should think about

Speaker:

risk,

Speaker:

what lawyers probably get wrong about risk and things that you

Speaker:

should be doing at your firms, regardless of the size,

Speaker:

to help you mitigate any risks that you have or as much as you can

Speaker:

possibly mitigate in the field that you're in. So Ben,

Speaker:

do you want to take us away?

Speaker:

Yeah, sure.

Speaker:

It's interesting you preface it by saying people might not want to listen

Speaker:

because when I hear the concept of risk,

Speaker:

I'm very interested and fascinated by it. So that would draw me in actually,

Speaker:

but I can understand the way you framed it.

Speaker:

It's interesting because I made a bullet list of things that relate to risk that

Speaker:

I wanted to talk about and you made a bullet list of things that relate to risk

Speaker:

that you wanted to talk about.

Speaker:

And I actually thought it was really fascinating to see the difference in our

Speaker:

lists because as you just alluded to,

Speaker:

it reflects your role and responsibility of the firm as our chief operating

Speaker:

officer,

Speaker:

but your list really went to ways to mitigate risk and to manage and reduce

Speaker:

risk.

Speaker:

As a trial lawyer who makes a living in contingent fee world,

Speaker:

strangely my list arguments for taking on greater risk. I think that's the

Speaker:

balance that every institution and individual lawyer

Speaker:

needs to think through when it comes to the concept of risk because the

Speaker:

idea that risk is a bad thing I think is incorrect.

Speaker:

I think that a lot of lawyers in particular,

Speaker:

because we tend to be very risk averse people that go into law,

Speaker:

don't take on enough risk and they lose opportunities because of their

Speaker:

risk aversion. And on the other hand,

Speaker:

you obviously need to build robust institutions that can withstand risk

Speaker:

and survive in order to take the next chance so that you continue to have

Speaker:

opportunities. So it's really always a careful balancing act.

Speaker:

You come from an industry, Jeff,

Speaker:

in the banking world where managing risk is really the entire business

Speaker:

model and it tends to be extremely conservative, right? I mean,

Speaker:

you've got billions of dollars under investment and you're making tiny,

Speaker:

tiny fractions of that in order to eke out a living. I'm

Speaker:

overstating the case,

Speaker:

but the banking world is really built on trying to reduce down to

Speaker:

almost no risk,

Speaker:

but yet still be able to generate some returns on the margins.

Speaker:

So talk about that a little bit and how that relates to your transition to a law

Speaker:

firm world.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think that was a great overview. I mean,

Speaker:

everything in the banking world was about risk and anyone here that has gone for

Speaker:

a loan or had a banking relationship, especially an in-person one,

Speaker:

not an online is every bank is going to do a risk profile on you.

Speaker:

That's where your credit score comes in. That's where debt to income comes in.

Speaker:

That's where your ability to repay and the loan to value comes in and

Speaker:

everything.

Speaker:

Some banks are extremely risk averse and they only want to take A

Speaker:

rated credit. If your credit's not above 750,

Speaker:

you're actually going to get charged a higher rate because that's how they

Speaker:

mitigate risk. Good people with good credit and good income,

Speaker:

they're going to get the most preferential rates. If you want a loan,

Speaker:

but you got some hair on your credit or your income,

Speaker:

you're going to get charged a few points higher and that's how the bank can

Speaker:

manage their risk by the offset. And then another big

Speaker:

thing outside of the lending is revenue streams.

Speaker:

Most banks look for what they call non-interest income.

Speaker:

The majority of traditional smaller banks,

Speaker:

not talking about the giant banks that have so many layers to them,

Speaker:

but a lot of their income comes from the interest and the spread

Speaker:

between what they're lending the money at and what they're paying the rates on

Speaker:

the deposit accounts and they keep the difference.

Speaker:

But non-interest income is what are their other revenue streams that they can

Speaker:

create? Non-interest income revenue streams. Is it fee income?

Speaker:

Is it ATM income?

Speaker:

Is it interchange income with your debit cards and things like that?

Speaker:

So it's definitely all about risk and it's

Speaker:

more so than anything I've been involved in in any other industry I've

Speaker:

worked.

Speaker:

In.

Speaker:

Is banking and risk and hedging it.

Speaker:

So you're the right guy to make sure we don't get out too far over our skis.

Speaker:

Hopefully.

Speaker:

Hopefully. So let me talk about,

Speaker:

you'd referenced in the title of the show,

Speaker:

how lawyers think about risk and what lawyers get wrong about risk.

Speaker:

I think that, as I mentioned, we tend to be very risk-averse crew.

Speaker:

If you probably remember back to law school and remember looking around in

Speaker:

your class,

Speaker:

a lot of people end up in law school because it's the straight narrow

Speaker:

path to a predictable, dependable career.

Speaker:

People that are taking the road less traveled,

Speaker:

they want to be poets or writers or musicians,

Speaker:

they're not in the seats next to you generally in law school.

Speaker:

It's people that are taking a more conventional path through life most of the

Speaker:

time. So I think lawyers self-select for, to some extent,

Speaker:

being risk-averse people. If you are listening to this podcast,

Speaker:

then you're in the smaller subset of lawyers who has already accepted the idea

Speaker:

of taking on greater risk than most lawyers do because building a law firm,

Speaker:

unlike just being an employed member of a firm or a different

Speaker:

lawyer job,

Speaker:

carries with it a little bit more risk. You're now entering the realm of

Speaker:

building a business and we've all heard about the statistics about the failure

Speaker:

rate of new businesses or small businesses.

Speaker:

We've talked about this a little bit in prior episode that that's a little bit

Speaker:

overblown when it comes to the lawyer world because building a law business

Speaker:

is not reinventing a business model that hasn't been tried and tested.

Speaker:

Basically, if you're competent at running a law firm,

Speaker:

you should be able to have success doing it because it's a

Speaker:

proven model.

Speaker:

There's a demand for legal services and there's not huge risk in that.

Speaker:

If you're doing a contingent fee type practice that we do where you're only

Speaker:

paid when you are successful with your case,

Speaker:

perhaps that involves slightly more risk,

Speaker:

but probably if you have enough inventory and diversity of work,

Speaker:

it also isn't particularly risky. Okay,

Speaker:

everybody here is slightly willing to absorb or take on a little bit more risk,

Speaker:

but I still think that even within that,

Speaker:

and even for lawyers building and managing their own law firms,

Speaker:

that risk aversion still tends to be a dominant feature and people don't

Speaker:

take on enough risk. This concept really crystallized for

Speaker:

me when I started thinking about the decisions about

Speaker:

whether to take particular cases to trial or to push them

Speaker:

further down the road rather than accepting settlements at different stages in

Speaker:

the case where there was significant money on the table and trying to think

Speaker:

through, okay,

Speaker:

does it make sense to settle this case or should I take the risk of pushing it

Speaker:

further to get a better, more outsized result?

Speaker:

And how does one even approach that question to come to

Speaker:

a rational and sensible answer to it?

Speaker:

What's the methodology?

Speaker:

Because far too often I think we just tend to rationalize decisions we

Speaker:

make based on something that if you were to evaluate it carefully,

Speaker:

it doesn't really stand up such as, well, my client wanted me to take the money.

Speaker:

Well, generally that's not true.

Speaker:

The client will do what you recommend or there's an issue in this case that

Speaker:

makes it almost impossible to win. Well,

Speaker:

is that really true or are you just rationalizing a early and

Speaker:

convenient settlement because most of the time many issues can be overcome if

Speaker:

you think creatively about them and so on and so forth.

Speaker:

And so that question about making decisions and considering

Speaker:

the risks of different choices caused me to start thinking about this more

Speaker:

seriously and I'm doing some reading on the subject.

Speaker:

And two of the books I read on this subject helped to inform my thinking and

Speaker:

views of risk. And one of those is a book by someone named Nate Silver,

Speaker:

and his book is called On the Edge: The Art of Risking Everything.

Speaker:

And there's another book by someone named Nassim Taleb who wrote a book called

Speaker:

The Black Swan.

Speaker:

And basically the thesis of these books,

Speaker:

Silver is a quasi-professional poker player who's also

Speaker:

heavily involved in sports betting and political

Speaker:

prognostications. He started a website called 538,

Speaker:

which many people may know that did probabilities of risks and success in

Speaker:

election campaigns.

Speaker:

His thesis was that there's really two general approaches to the idea

Speaker:

of risk. And one is what's embraced by people who work in Silicon Valley,

Speaker:

entrepreneurs, venture capitalists and so forth.

Speaker:

And they look at the world similar to how a professional poker player looks at

Speaker:

poker.

Speaker:

They look at it from a mathematical and probabilistic standpoint

Speaker:

of how do I maximize my returns over a period of time?

Speaker:

And that involves looking at factors such as what there is

Speaker:

to be gained and the probabilities of loss,

Speaker:

less at whether you're going to win every hand. And I think with lawyers,

Speaker:

we tend to think about losing even a single hand or a single case,

Speaker:

or maybe if it's in your business,

Speaker:

a single business venture or opportunity that you may try. We're very risk

Speaker:

averse to that, even a single loss on anything.

Speaker:

We view success as getting small victories on everything,

Speaker:

but what he points out is that over time,

Speaker:

that isn't the best way to maximize your opportunities because you're not

Speaker:

taking enough risks where there's a lot at stake where there could be very,

Speaker:

very high upside for you if you were to venture into that and give it a shot.

Speaker:

The Black Swan book by Nassim Taleb had kind of a similar thesis,

Speaker:

which is that the things that tend to be most impactful in terms of changing the

Speaker:

course of history,

Speaker:

changing individual financial performance are things that

Speaker:

tend to be unexpected and unpredictable to most people,

Speaker:

what he would call a "Black Swan" event and that you

Speaker:

maximize your opportunities for those asymmetric returns

Speaker:

by lining up Black Swan events so that if they go in an unexpected

Speaker:

way,

Speaker:

you're in a position to benefit from them rather than being in a position where

Speaker:

you're going to be similarly situated to everybody else where the same

Speaker:

unexpected event is going to cause challenges or devastation to you the same way

Speaker:

it will to everybody else. You're the person,

Speaker:

if you recognize the possibility of it,

Speaker:

can take advantage of that unexpected or unpredictable event. And again,

Speaker:

in our line of work as a trial lawyer,

Speaker:

that's actually something we deal with all the time because there are many cases

Speaker:

where there's conventional thinking about what the likely result would be at

Speaker:

trial, for example,

Speaker:

where the Black Swan event would be getting an outsized or unexpected verdict,

Speaker:

but that happens a lot more often than you'd think.

Speaker:

And so how can you be in a position to benefit from that unpredictable

Speaker:

outcome from the case with that exceptionally great verdict that other people

Speaker:

didn't see coming, but you know is going to come now and that.

Speaker:

So I'm going to stop there. That's a lot of stuff.

Speaker:

I'm sorry to throw all that out,

Speaker:

but I wanted to get it out there on the table so we can discuss. So how do these

Speaker:

concepts strike you, Jeff?

Speaker:

What I've learned in my two years here is I think any firm or any especially

Speaker:

contingent fee firm is not going to be the most

Speaker:

successful firm out there without taking a certain amount of risk.

Speaker:

I think you're limiting your growth opportunities,

Speaker:

you're limiting your potential for outsized verdicts,

Speaker:

like you said.

Speaker:

I guess my question to you is how do you rationalize the

Speaker:

difference between calculated risk and reckless risk or

Speaker:

unnecessary risk or whatever the opposite of calculated risk is?

Speaker:

And because every attorney is such a competitive person,

Speaker:

to keep yourself reined in enough to just take well thought out

Speaker:

calculated risks and not unnecessary risks out of ego or

Speaker:

spite or simple desire to win.

Speaker:

It's got to be something you struggle with.

Speaker:

That question goes to the heart of so many risk-based decisions

Speaker:

and is incredibly important because what I am not advocating

Speaker:

is to throw caution to the wind to take crazy risks for

Speaker:

the benefit of your own personal ego or aggrandizement or

Speaker:

enrichment at the expense of your clients.

Speaker:

That's absolutely not what I'm suggesting at all.

Speaker:

And I can understand how someone listening might have drawn that thinking,

Speaker:

but where I'm coming from is sort of the opposite,

Speaker:

which is that we tend to be extremely risk averse and we have to also

Speaker:

acknowledge that in order to get to a equilibrium where we can

Speaker:

appropriately evaluate risks.

Speaker:

If there's a case that involves a decision, it could be a risk in the case.

Speaker:

There's also systemic risks to the practice,

Speaker:

but that's a different set of risks than individual cases because for our

Speaker:

practice or any law practice as a whole,

Speaker:

and I don't mean it just to mean a decision to try a case or settle

Speaker:

a case,

Speaker:

it can be for a different practice. It could be the risk of

Speaker:

taking on a new line of work that you've never done before and

Speaker:

investing money in it.

Speaker:

It could be the risk of marketing and putting dollars behind something,

Speaker:

not knowing what's coming in.

Speaker:

It could be the risk of expanding into another geographic market.

Speaker:

It could be the risk of you going and giving a speech to a high level

Speaker:

professional group where you might get referrals from that,

Speaker:

but if you perform poorly, it might damage your reputation. I mean,

Speaker:

there's so many things.

Speaker:

It involves anything where you have to put yourself out there and expand

Speaker:

beyond your core comfort level to try to make something happen for yourself.

Speaker:

If you're building a law firm,

Speaker:

the easiest thing to do is to do what you already know

Speaker:

how to do and to do that in volume and then to

Speaker:

use volume to geometrically or linearly

Speaker:

expand your revenues,

Speaker:

gradually eventually hiring people to handle some of the

Speaker:

volume,

Speaker:

but just expanding linearly in that way. And we get into

Speaker:

the difference of quality versus volume,

Speaker:

but that is not the right way to scale and it is not the right way to have

Speaker:

outsized success.

Speaker:

Building McDonald's as a law firm is probably not going to be your best

Speaker:

approach.

Speaker:

The better approach is to find something where you can burnish a

Speaker:

reputation that allows you to create a value proposition to do

Speaker:

high value cases where the margins are much higher than the

Speaker:

volume practice. With the volume practice, you're competing with everybody.

Speaker:

With the high-margin reputation-based practice,

Speaker:

you might be competing with almost nobody, but how do you get to that point?

Speaker:

Well, it requires you taking risks.

Speaker:

It requires you to eschew the easy skillset and tasks

Speaker:

that you're good at and can just replicate over and over and become known for

Speaker:

something else. Well,

Speaker:

how do you do that? And then that goes back to choices you make and risks you

Speaker:

take. So it really spans the whole range of things we're talking about.

Speaker:

It's not just decisions on an individual case.

Speaker:

That's a long background,

Speaker:

but to go back to your question of how do you make sure you're not

Speaker:

making decisions based on bad motives or reckless

Speaker:

conduct,

Speaker:

what I think is really critical is to do the self-reflection

Speaker:

on when you've got critical decision points,

Speaker:

what is really driving your decision at that point?

Speaker:

And to explore that,

Speaker:

I think it's useful to understand the concepts in this book by

Speaker:

Daniel Kahneman called Thinking Fast and Thinking Slow.

Speaker:

It's an award-winning book. I think Kahneman and Tversky, his partner,

Speaker:

won a Nobel Prize for their research into this area,

Speaker:

but what they do is demonstrate how so many of our decisions

Speaker:

are the result of deep-seated cognitive biases that we

Speaker:

don't even appreciate are driving those decisions. So some

Speaker:

examples of that would be the concept that people tend to

Speaker:

perceive the pain of a loss as a higher value than the

Speaker:

pleasure of a gain.

Speaker:

So people therefore become averse to risk because

Speaker:

they don't want to lose something, even though what they may stand to gain,

Speaker:

if you just did the probabilistic analysis of that,

Speaker:

is on average more than what they would lose. They're going to lose sometimes,

Speaker:

they're going to win sometimes, but if you average it all out,

Speaker:

the winnings are going to exceed the losing,

Speaker:

but yet people still don't want to do that because they're worried or they

Speaker:

overvalue the concern of the loss.

Speaker:

That's something called prospect theory or risk-averse theory.

Speaker:

There's also the concept that they explored that people value things they

Speaker:

already own more than things that they don't own yet.

Speaker:

So if you have money in the bank as a law firm,

Speaker:

you tend to value that more than what that money invested in the

Speaker:

right things might produce later because you already have it,

Speaker:

but the other thing you don't have yet. So it might make sense to spend the

Speaker:

money to get a higher return later,

Speaker:

but people are averse to doing that.

Speaker:

That's something called the endowment effect.

Speaker:

And then there's a bunch of things that dictate decisions based on what they

Speaker:

call heuristics,

Speaker:

which are basically mental shortcuts we all use and don't even realize we're

Speaker:

using them,

Speaker:

such as we tend to fear things that are dramatic

Speaker:

and publicly reported,

Speaker:

like airplane crashes or shark attacks that greatly overstate the risk of

Speaker:

those kinds of things ever happening.

Speaker:

Whereas we underappreciate much more common but less dramatic

Speaker:

risks like getting into a car accident on your drive to work.

Speaker:

And we also make a lot of assumptions through stereotypes or recent

Speaker:

experiences. So for instance,

Speaker:

if you recently had a case and you got this particular bad

Speaker:

outcome or bad result or you did X and it didn't work out well,

Speaker:

then anytime you see something similar to that,

Speaker:

your assumption is it's going to go that way as it did in the past,

Speaker:

even though that might have been an aberration and nine times out of 10 it

Speaker:

would've gone the other way. So step one is before you make a decision,

Speaker:

search yourself and decide are you making a decision based on a clearheaded

Speaker:

assessment of the true risk,

Speaker:

the probability of success multiplied by the risk of failure,

Speaker:

what they would call expected value calculation,

Speaker:

or are you actually making decisions based on one of these cognitive biases that

Speaker:

is skewing your thinking about the choice you have in front of you?

Speaker:

And that process of just even asking yourself that question answers a lot of

Speaker:

what you just asked because if you are throwing caution to the wind and

Speaker:

making reckless choices,

Speaker:

then you are making your decision for a bad reason,

Speaker:

some cognitive bias or some,

Speaker:

"I think that this case is going to generate a hundred million dollars because

Speaker:

my friend in California just tried a similar case in Los Angeles

Speaker:

County and got a hundred million dollar verdict." That would be the availability

Speaker:

heuristic at play,

Speaker:

right? That does not in any way compute to a rational

Speaker:

reason for your belief about that case.

Speaker:

That is a cognitive bias at play. Or the contrary thing, "Well,

Speaker:

I'm pretty sure that this is a really bad case because I heard about somebody

Speaker:

who tried a similar case last week and they got a bad verdict or I don't think I

Speaker:

should extend myself out to move into this area of practice

Speaker:

because I've been told that other people have failed in that."

Speaker:

So that's just, again,

Speaker:

that's you applying a cognitive bias that isn't rational and you

Speaker:

should recognize that and then break that down and try to figure out, okay,

Speaker:

but putting that aside, what are the reasons for doing it?

Speaker:

And then what are the reasons against doing it?

Speaker:

And carefully analyze that so you come to a logical decision about how

Speaker:

best to manage that risk rather than just a knee-jerk reaction to the

Speaker:

bias.

Speaker:

Need help on a complex personal injury or medical malpractice case?

Speaker:

Gideon Asen accepts case referrals and regularly co-counsels with lawyers

Speaker:

nationwide on high value claims.

Speaker:

The firm has recovered millions of dollars in cases that competitors turned away

Speaker:

because they dig deeper. Ready to learn more?

Speaker:

Email bgideon@gideonasenlaw.com to start the conversation.

Speaker:

Gideon Asen shares fees as permitted by the laws of each state.

Speaker:

Don't let complex cases overwhelm your practice.

Speaker:

Elevate justice together with Gideon Asen.

Speaker:

Let me ask you this, Ben. So for those listeners,

Speaker:

we have two owner partners here, Ben and Taylor.

Speaker:

Someone asked me to describe how I see each of you with risk.

Speaker:

I would say you are more of a risk seeker and Taylor is more risk tolerant.

Speaker:

I don't think Taylor's averse to risk,

Speaker:

but he's more risk tolerant and you are more willing to seek out risk.

Speaker:

How important is it to kind of have that counterbalance with a partner?

Speaker:

And I think it would be,

Speaker:

especially if someone's starting a firm and they're looking for a partner,

Speaker:

if you had two very aggressive,

Speaker:

very risk seeking partners and there's no counterbalance there,

Speaker:

how difficult do you think that would be?

Speaker:

Well,

Speaker:

it's interesting you should say that because when we did our TIPS profile,

Speaker:

our psychological profile that we all took ourselves and we have all of our new

Speaker:

employees or people we're vetting for jobs take,

Speaker:

I actually was pretty low on the risk scale and Taylor was higher.

Speaker:

I know, which made no sense whatsoever.

Speaker:

I believe it does because I do take risks,

Speaker:

but I believe that the risks I'm taking are in line with the methodology I'm

Speaker:

explaining right now and that they're all thought through because I'm very

Speaker:

careful about how I'm thinking about that risk I'm taking.

Speaker:

Taylor tends to be more of a fly by the seat of his pants person.

Speaker:

So he will take risks in the sense of just kind of shooting first,

Speaker:

asking questions later,

Speaker:

which allows him to be very nimble and act quickly,

Speaker:

which has its benefits for sure.

Speaker:

Whereas I tend to think through issues more carefully and deliberately before

Speaker:

doing them so I can sometimes become a little bit stuck or paralyzed to the

Speaker:

thought process.

Speaker:

So I do think that quickness versus deliberate thing,

Speaker:

definitely it's a good yin and yang to have in your practice,

Speaker:

but I actually think I am more risk averse than Taylor,

Speaker:

even though I do tend to take the risks when the risks need to be taken.

Speaker:

But I think I am very cautious about risks that I want to take.

Speaker:

We talk sometimes about a case we tried against an $11 million offer where we

Speaker:

turned it down and went to verdict and we lost.

Speaker:

That was my decision and the client obviously, but

Speaker:

that went to - there was enormous thought that went into that question because

Speaker:

that seemed like a lot of money to turn down,

Speaker:

particularly in the venue and with some of the facts we knew about the case,

Speaker:

but we had a lot of data on that.

Speaker:

We had tested it numerous times and we genuinely

Speaker:

believed,

Speaker:

and the data that we had seemed to suggest that the case had a actual value,

Speaker:

many multiples of that $11 million that was offered.

Speaker:

So I didn't view that as taking a risk.

Speaker:

I viewed that as the logical decision rather than acting on my

Speaker:

fear of loss or the cognitive bias of trying to

Speaker:

rationalize something that made me less uncomfortable,

Speaker:

which would've been easy to take the money. I did the more uncomfortable thing,

Speaker:

but the thing that was more in line with the right risk calculation for that

Speaker:

case. So I know it can be viewed in a different way, particularly in hindsight,

Speaker:

right?

Speaker:

And that's not how you can view the concept of risk because when you're making

Speaker:

the decision, you don't know what the outcome will be at that point.

Speaker:

Nate Silver gives a great example in his book about playing a poker hand.

Speaker:

He was at the World Series of Poker and he,

Speaker:

like all professional poker players can essentially calculate using game theory

Speaker:

and just numbers of what cards are on the table and in his hand,

Speaker:

he can calculate the risk of success in any individual hand.

Speaker:

He knew based on what was in his hand that he had effectively the

Speaker:

second best hand anyone could possibly have with a set of cards that was on the

Speaker:

table. And we're talking about Texas Hold'em.

Speaker:

So there's a series of cards down on the table and then each player has two

Speaker:

cards in their hand and they have to put together the best combined hand.

Speaker:

And so this was a televised poker hand.

Speaker:

He was pretty far along in the World Series of Poker and playing this hand.

Speaker:

So there was a lot at stake and he went all in on the hand and he

Speaker:

lost because there was another player at the table who had the one hand

Speaker:

that could beat the hand he had.

Speaker:

And his point in the aftermath of that was if I had to play that same hand

Speaker:

a hundred times, I would play it the same way a hundred times.

Speaker:

Because if you don't go all in on that hand,

Speaker:

then you shouldn't be playing poker because it's obviously from expected value,

Speaker:

meaning the likelihood of success multiplied by what you can gain from that

Speaker:

hand in terms of winning that round, winning what's in the pot,

Speaker:

that is the right move. I mean, of course,

Speaker:

if you knew the other player had the other hand and could read people perfectly

Speaker:

like that, and I don't believe anybody can do so, but if you could,

Speaker:

that would be different, but you can't.

Speaker:

So that's the point that there are going to be hands and choices you make to go

Speaker:

all in to do something that is the right choice. It doesn't mean it's risk-free.

Speaker:

And that's the whole idea of risk,

Speaker:

that making those right risk calculations in the right moments can pay

Speaker:

huge dividends. And I think as lawyers,

Speaker:

this is the part that we often don't factor in and we

Speaker:

should,

Speaker:

is the question of the secondary and third

Speaker:

level and beyond outcomes or effects of

Speaker:

decisions that we make.

Speaker:

In a case where you decide to take a case all the way to

Speaker:

trial and you win that trial,

Speaker:

the immediate effect of that is where you're going to get a good result in that

Speaker:

case. Maybe you're going to get a good verdict.

Speaker:

But then there's the secondary result.

Speaker:

That might be that you're going to get a better settlement for other clients

Speaker:

that you have in cases that you're currently working on because they will

Speaker:

see the verdict you got and be willing to pay you more in each of those cases.

Speaker:

Then there's the third level consequence,

Speaker:

which is you're going to enhance your reputation.

Speaker:

You're going to get better cases because you're perceived as someone who can get

Speaker:

those verdicts and so on and so forth because you're going to get better cases

Speaker:

that will lead to better verdicts, better settlements and so forth.

Speaker:

So now you viewed your one decision as do I take this case to trial or

Speaker:

not with the primary consequence of the verdict in that case versus not,

Speaker:

but actually the consequences, the secondary,

Speaker:

the third level consequences and all of the other ones combined could be a

Speaker:

career changing event for you that you're squandering by being too

Speaker:

risk averse. And I think that applies across the board, right?

Speaker:

The lawyer who just sticks to churning through the volume of the

Speaker:

thing they know they're already good at,

Speaker:

but is pretty routine that everybody else can do.

Speaker:

You can eke out a decent living like that with low margin work building

Speaker:

that up over time. But if you take on the risk of, well,

Speaker:

I'm going to become an expert in this one thing,

Speaker:

my friend who was on our podcast,

Speaker:

cryptocurrency litigation involving financial fraud and crypto,

Speaker:

something very few people have high level expertise in,

Speaker:

but you don't really have a lot in it initially. You have to invest time in it.

Speaker:

You have to go to conferences, you might have to read books and give speeches.

Speaker:

You might have to take on a couple cases that don't monetize early because

Speaker:

your clients don't have the capability to pay or you don't know what you're

Speaker:

doing right away and you aren't successful,

Speaker:

but you need to think about what is the secondary consequence of that? What is

Speaker:

the third level consequence of that?

Speaker:

Where does that decision to take on that risk now leave me in five or 10

Speaker:

years?

Speaker:

And I think those are the things that as lawyers we need to really devote more

Speaker:

time and consideration to on the risk side.

Speaker:

On the flip side of all of that though,

Speaker:

and I want to turn it over to you on this and it segues from what we did the

Speaker:

last episode on financial planning, I'm very aware as we all should be,

Speaker:

that none of us are going to be around in five or 10 years unless we build a

Speaker:

resilient operation and firm that gives

Speaker:

us the luxury and freedom to take on the kind of risks I'm

Speaker:

just saying. Because honestly, you have to earn the right to do that.

Speaker:

You can't start a firm, have no revenue stream and say, "Oh,

Speaker:

well I'm just going to start off by taking a bunch of risks." You won't be

Speaker:

around long enough to see the fruits of that. And so the things you had

Speaker:

on your list, Jeff,

Speaker:

really are more designed to manage risk from that standpoint,

Speaker:

to make sure we're still around long enough to execute our plans.

Speaker:

Yeah. Before I get into those,

Speaker:

having only been in this world for two years,

Speaker:

I'm fascinated at the process. And when we're talking about risk,

Speaker:

almost every step you have to make a decision based upon risk and kind of the

Speaker:

genesis of a case where you get the case,

Speaker:

you're assuming the risk of taking on that case and whether you think it's a

Speaker:

good case to take on and a winnable case.

Speaker:

And then from there you make a demand and they come back with an offer well

Speaker:

below your demand.

Speaker:

You're taking a risk turning down that offer and then it's going to mediation.

Speaker:

You're taking a risk, probably turning down a higher offer.

Speaker:

You decide to take it to trial, which is a risk.

Speaker:

And then maybe to mitigate your risk more during the trial,

Speaker:

you come up with a high low agreement. So all the way through,

Speaker:

you're almost assessing risk and whether it makes sense to take it to the

Speaker:

next step,

Speaker:

which is a more aggressive step. It's really fascinating to watch and I probably

Speaker:

missed 48 steps in that explanation,

Speaker:

but seeing it as a non-attorney happen is just fascinating.

Speaker:

To Ben's point about coming from the operations world and kind of the opposite

Speaker:

of what Ben was talking about are things that we feel every firm should be doing

Speaker:

and what we try and do to mitigate your risks.

Speaker:

And we had talked about one on our previous episode about budgeting and

Speaker:

finances,

Speaker:

especially if you have a contingent fee business with unpredictable lumpy

Speaker:

income. I forgot who it was the other day said,

Speaker:

"How much money are you going to make this quarter?" And it's like, well,

Speaker:

somewhere between zero and a hundred million dollars because we actually have no

Speaker:

idea even though we try and predict it as well as possible.

Speaker:

But when you get to a point established what we call as a rainy day fund,

Speaker:

you're going to have slow months. You're going to have a slow quarter.

Speaker:

You're going to have a situation that Ben explained where you turn down

Speaker:

an $11 million offer and it goes south on you.

Speaker:

You're not going to win every case or get every settlement to be an outsized

Speaker:

settlement. You have to have a rainy day fund,

Speaker:

a backup plan, enough money,

Speaker:

especially to keep your firm operating where when you do have

Speaker:

a challenge, it's not going to throw the firm into a major problem. Two,

Speaker:

I think you have to look at your case mix and your pipeline. As you know,

Speaker:

we're a med mal firm and catastrophic PI and we do do some, you know,

Speaker:

1983 civil rights, but primarily catastrophic PI and med mal.

Speaker:

If we were 90% med mal and 10% PI mix,

Speaker:

that would be much more concerning and much riskier.

Speaker:

So looking at your case mix,

Speaker:

is it diversified in the different types and also,

Speaker:

is it top-heavy? A lot of businesses - we're in this case - 80%

Speaker:

of your revenue is going to be derived from maybe 10 or 15% of your

Speaker:

clients.

Speaker:

And if you're really hanging your hat or putting all your eggs in one basket

Speaker:

that you have this one case that you really think can be an eight-figure

Speaker:

case - if that case goes south,

Speaker:

do you have enough diversification in your pipeline where losing that

Speaker:

case is not going to put you out of business?

Speaker:

Another thing is how are you getting your cases?

Speaker:

How reliant on you is your firm to say one referral source?

Speaker:

Are you getting the majority of your cases through referrals?

Speaker:

Are you getting the majority of your cases through B2B or B2C?

Speaker:

And are you overly dependent in one area?

Speaker:

If you have five firms that are giving you all your cases and you're 100%

Speaker:

reliant on them,

Speaker:

what if you piss off one of those firms or two of those firms or they decide to

Speaker:

work with somebody else that's going to pay them a higher fee split or

Speaker:

something? How are you diversifying how you're gathering your cases?

Speaker:

Locations and competition. What's your market like?

Speaker:

When's the last time you actually looked at your market?

Speaker:

And if it's a small market, a large market, a competitive market,

Speaker:

an overly saturated market, when's the last time you looked at it?

Speaker:

Are you a med mal firm and your competition,

Speaker:

there's 40 other med mal firms within 30 miles of you and you're all fighting

Speaker:

for the same cases?

Speaker:

Have you assessed other locations or other geographic areas,

Speaker:

other states or other practice areas where there may be an

Speaker:

opportunity to expand appropriately and mitigate your risk so you're not

Speaker:

banging your head against the wall against 50 other firms?

Speaker:

And probably the last thing, and we've talked staffing before,

Speaker:

but when you look at your staff,

Speaker:

whether you have seven people in your firm or 70,

Speaker:

are there one or two key people that if you lost them,

Speaker:

there would be a significant disruption in your firm? And I'll

Speaker:

caution that because everyone's going to say,

Speaker:

"If I lost Betty or if I lost John, I wouldn't know what to do.

Speaker:

They have so much institutional knowledge." I would say 96% of the

Speaker:

time, your fear is a lot worse than reality,

Speaker:

but a lot of firms will have one or two individuals handling

Speaker:

multiple things that are absolutely critical to your firm.

Speaker:

And if they left, there would be a disruption.

Speaker:

So what are you doing to cross-train?

Speaker:

What are you doing to build bench strength that in the event that individual was

Speaker:

no longer there or was out of for an extended leave,

Speaker:

there would not be a disruption to your firm that would be critical?

Speaker:

Those are just some things that I think every firm can do to mitigate

Speaker:

risk really on a daily basis and it's not a heavy,

Speaker:

heavy lift to do those things.

Speaker:

Yeah, it's really important. And I mean, I've always, as I said before,

Speaker:

viewed the opportunity to take calculated risks as a luxury.

Speaker:

It's something that I feel you earn by doing the things you just

Speaker:

said so that you're not building on a house of cards.

Speaker:

You have a strong foundation of resilience and that allows you to

Speaker:

occasionally take on intelligent risks where there's

Speaker:

opportunities.

Speaker:

So an example in line with what you're just saying,

Speaker:

we recently decided to join forces and acquire a Vermont law

Speaker:

practice,

Speaker:

bringing on two seasoned Vermont lawyers who we know well and have worked well

Speaker:

with in cases in the past and to expand geographically into the state of

Speaker:

Vermont. So full-time office presence there,

Speaker:

start to take on more cases there.

Speaker:

That's a risk because rather than just focusing like a laser

Speaker:

in the markets where we already have a good penetration and a lot of dominance,

Speaker:

we're moving into a new market that we don't understand as well or we're not as

Speaker:

well known, you could say, well,

Speaker:

there's a risk there. And probably five years ago,

Speaker:

we wouldn't have been positioned to take that risk,

Speaker:

but now we've built up a lot of our internal systems and structures

Speaker:

and staffing and have the confidence that we can take that on.

Speaker:

We carefully vetted the pros and cons and risks of it,

Speaker:

but it's a risk that we felt very comfortable taking,

Speaker:

but only because we had done the hard work to position ourselves to take

Speaker:

advantage of that opportunity.

Speaker:

And I think that when we talk about individual cases,

Speaker:

it's the same way where as devastated as I was for our client,

Speaker:

particularly that we did not win the case where we turned the $11 million down,

Speaker:

of course, in retrospect, knowing what would've happened, I very,

Speaker:

very much regret the decision to do that even though I still believe from a risk

Speaker:

standpoint it was the correct decision and nine times out of 10,

Speaker:

we would have been better off and the client would have obtained a better result

Speaker:

from that decision,

Speaker:

but that was anomalous occasion where the risk came back the wrong

Speaker:

way for us. But even from a systemic standpoint from our law firm's

Speaker:

health,

Speaker:

we had a good year that year because we had many other cases,

Speaker:

we had many other verdicts and settlements and success in

Speaker:

other areas that afforded us the opportunity to take on that risk

Speaker:

without an existential threat to the business.

Speaker:

So in a sense,

Speaker:

we had earned the right to at least make that

Speaker:

calculated risk judgment,

Speaker:

which would not have been easy to make if that was our only case, right?

Speaker:

If that was our only case, we would've been out of business.

Speaker:

So we're coming close to the time,

Speaker:

but one of the things we've done well,

Speaker:

I think in terms of grappling with these issues is number one,

Speaker:

to start with the idea of recognizing when we're making

Speaker:

decisions based on cognitive bias or factors other than a

Speaker:

clear-eyed view of the right cost benefit and rational

Speaker:

evaluation of the real risks. So we've done that well.

Speaker:

Part of that is having a leadership team with you and Taylor and Meryl where

Speaker:

we thoughtfully discuss issues that come up that would cause us

Speaker:

to need to take a risk, whether it's hiring a new lawyer,

Speaker:

building out a new office space, expanding into a new geographic territory,

Speaker:

running new TV marketing campaign, whatever.

Speaker:

We have thorough discussions about them where people are free to raise

Speaker:

questions, to challenge the issue,

Speaker:

to come up with their own view of it and test it out,

Speaker:

stress test it in that setting. So we do that, that's number one. Number two,

Speaker:

we developed a case matrix,

Speaker:

which we used in one of our most significant cases to try to quantify

Speaker:

and evaluate the specific risks of moving forward with a

Speaker:

case towards trial or trying it versus settling it at different junctures.

Speaker:

And even though we haven't adopted that for use in every case,

Speaker:

the concepts that we identified there I think are ones that we now regularly

Speaker:

think about in every case. And the matrix is something we probably should adopt

Speaker:

or use more, but it reflects things such as the time value of money.

Speaker:

You may settle the case today for X,

Speaker:

you may take it to trial a year from now and you might get a better result,

Speaker:

but what's the time value of money that you've lost out on during that

Speaker:

timeframe?

Speaker:

What's the additional costs to litigate that case for the next year?

Speaker:

And not just in terms of out-of-pocket expenses,

Speaker:

but the cost in terms of resources,

Speaker:

staff devoted to that case and the opportunity cost of the

Speaker:

cases that same staff and lawyers were not able to work on because they were

Speaker:

focused on this case.

Speaker:

So maybe the marginal difference in value of case

Speaker:

A, you're going to get a better result,

Speaker:

but not enough of a better result that it justifies that

Speaker:

additional out-of-pocket expense and staff resource time,

Speaker:

whereas they could take another case that currently has zero value and turn it

Speaker:

into some value that's more than the value they've added in case A,

Speaker:

right? And then not just that,

Speaker:

but what are the secondary impacts of that?

Speaker:

What are the third level impacts of that, right?

Speaker:

If we take this particular case to trial and get,

Speaker:

we recently did,

Speaker:

we got the highest malpractice and personal injury verdict ever in the state of

Speaker:

Maine,

Speaker:

that verdict has more value to us than just the monetary

Speaker:

value of the verdict.

Speaker:

It has significant value in terms of our firm's reputation,

Speaker:

in terms of our ability to market,

Speaker:

also the internal relationships and collaboration that go

Speaker:

into trying a lengthy case that build unity and cohesiveness among our

Speaker:

teams and give our younger lawyers an opportunity to be in the courtroom and try

Speaker:

cases.

Speaker:

There's a lot of other non-economic things that go into

Speaker:

really every opportunity you are considering.

Speaker:

And so giving a value to those things, listing them out,

Speaker:

discussing them as real tangible things that you'd be losing or

Speaker:

gaining if you took one approach versus the other. Many of these things cannot

Speaker:

be quantified in precise dollars and cents or precise risk

Speaker:

probabilities like a poker hand. Now poker is,

Speaker:

there's game theory and it's a closed data set really where

Speaker:

you can precisely calculate values.

Speaker:

You can't do that in a lot of business decisions or in a lot of case management

Speaker:

decisions, but if you attempt to do the same exercise,

Speaker:

identify the pros and cons,

Speaker:

try to place either economic value or some placeholder for economic

Speaker:

value and then have robust discussions around that,

Speaker:

I think you will ultimately come to better decisions about risk and you'll be

Speaker:

surprised at where that leads you.

Speaker:

It won't always be the intuitive decision you though.

Speaker:

You will find yourself, I think, again, going back to lawyers being risk averse,

Speaker:

you will find yourself feeling emboldened to take on some more

Speaker:

calculated risks and those can be life changing for you

Speaker:

and for your law practice over longer term. Jeff,

Speaker:

let's wrap it up. What do you got? Final thoughts?

Speaker:

Final thoughts are that was a lot more interesting than the title of the show.

Speaker:

It was good. I think the big takeaway is,

Speaker:

especially with our case settlement matrix that you were talking about,

Speaker:

and it's very difficult to quantify everything in there,

Speaker:

people do not look beyond the dollars and there were so many other factors.

Speaker:

They're saying, "Well, we could take two million,

Speaker:

but I think I can get four million at trial." There was so much more that should

Speaker:

go into that thought process beyond the dollars.

Speaker:

And then Ben mentioned 15 things off the top of his head and you really have to

Speaker:

look at that to get an entire risk profile and risk picture.

Speaker:

Just look beyond the dollars. It's way too superficial. But no,

Speaker:

good strong show, Ben.

Speaker:

Yeah, it was great, Jeff. Thanks as always.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening to Elawvate: Build and Grow Your Law Firm.

Speaker:

Share with colleagues if you found it valuable. Remember,

Speaker:

building a successful law firm takes discipline, strategy, and determination,

Speaker:

but you're not alone. Produced and powered by LawPods.